In Alonso’s defence, Chelsea had problems before his arrival.
They finished 10th last season, having been outrun in 37 of their 38 matches, and had three managers during a chaotic campaign.
Remarkably, Chelsea have seven more points from corresponding fixtures this season and last, but it mostly serves to show how low the bar was set.
Champions League qualification was again the club’s pre-season target and Alonso’s appointment was designed to bring stability and authority.
The former Real Madrid and Liverpool midfielder had an impressive playing career and earned much early admiration as a manager, guiding Bayer Leverkusen to a league and cup double in 2024.
However, the Spaniard, who was sacked by Real Madrid last season, has yet to establish any real consistency – beyond his defence leaking goals regularly.
Only Crystal Palace, Coventry City and Ipswich Town have conceded more goals than Chelsea this season.
Chelsea are also now averaging fewer than a goal per game since Joao Pedro suffered a thigh injury in training. Alongside Pedro and now Caicedo, Jorrel Hato, Maxence Lacroix, Reece James and Jamie Gittens are also injured.
It highlights how they have gained little benefit of having a season without European football.
Alonso is also beginning to face criticism from sections of the fanbase for both his team selections and substitutions.
Chief among the reasons is the constant chopping and changing of the starting XI, having now made 28 line-up changes (behind only Tottenham) while also switching between back-four and back-three systems.
In addition, Alonso is being criticised for his use of personnel, having deployed Pedro Neto as a striker on two occasions and, some would argue, not made enough use of exciting young winger Estevao.